top of page
Writer's pictureDaniel Barber

Chapter 44: The Investigation Begins

Three men searching for the truth, one holds it.
The scent grew stronger inside.



The journey to Mr. Jameson’s home was a somber one. The carriage rattled over cobblestone streets as Holmes sat in deep contemplation, his brow furrowed and eyes distant.


I knew better than to interrupt his train of thought, so I remained silent, content to observe the rain-slicked city as it passed by. Mr. Jameson, on the other hand, fidgeted nervously, his fingers drumming against his knees as he glanced anxiously out the window.


When we finally arrived, the Jameson residence loomed before us, a stark contrast to the bustling streets of central Winston-Salem. It was a large, stately home, yet there was an undeniable air of neglect about the place. The ivy that clung to its walls seemed less decorative than it did a symbol of the slow encroachment of time and decay. The windows, dark and uninviting, gave the impression of a house that had long since withdrawn from the world.


Holmes stepped out of the carriage, his sharp eyes sweeping over the property with the meticulous attention to detail that had made him famous. I could see him taking in everything—the overgrown garden, the cracked stone path leading to the front door, and the subtle sag in the roof that suggested the building had settled unevenly over the years.


“This house,” Holmes murmured as we approached the door, “has seen better days. It is not merely the exterior, Watson, but what lies beneath that concerns me.”


Before I could ask what he meant, Mr. Jameson led us inside. The interior was much as I had expected from the outside—a once-grand home now faded by the passage of time. The furniture, though of fine quality, was worn and outdated. Dust clung to the surfaces, and the dim light from the windows did little to dispel the gloom that seemed to permeate every room.


As we entered the main hallway, that peculiar odor Mr. Jameson had described grew more pronounced. It was a sickly, cloying smell that made my nose wrinkle in discomfort. Holmes, however, appeared unperturbed, his keen senses already working to pinpoint its origin.


“This way, Mr. Holmes,” Jameson said, leading us through the house. “I’ll show you the kitchen first. That’s where the smell was initially strongest.”


We followed him into the kitchen, which, despite its size, felt cramped and oppressive. The smell was indeed stronger here, and I noticed a faint dampness in the air that hinted at something more than just a surface-level problem.


Holmes began his examination immediately. He moved with purpose, his gaze sharp and focused as he inspected the room. He paused by the sink, running his hand along the edge of the counter before bending down to examine the plumbing beneath. He tapped the pipes lightly, listening for any irregularities, and then straightened up, his expression unreadable.


“Mr. Jameson,” Holmes said, “how long have you lived in this house?”


“Nearly twenty years, Mr. Holmes,” Jameson replied. “It’s been in my family for generations, but I’m afraid it has not been kept up as well as it should have been. I always thought of it as an old, sturdy place—until now.”


Holmes nodded, his eyes narrowing slightly. “And during those twenty years, have you ever had the septic system inspected?”


Jameson looked puzzled. “The septic system? I can’t say that I’ve given it much thought. It’s never caused any issues before.”


“That, Mr. Jameson, is precisely the problem,” Holmes said, his tone clipped but not unkind. “Neglecting a septic system, especially in a house of this age, can lead to severe consequences. Tell me, have you noticed any changes in the soil around the house? Any unusual dampness or patches of ground that seem to be sinking?”


Jameson’s eyes widened slightly. “Now that you mention it, yes. There’s a spot near the back of the house where the ground has become quite soft, almost boggy. I thought it was just due to the recent rain.”


Holmes exchanged a brief glance with me before turning back to Jameson. “That soft ground may be the result of your septic system failing, Mr. Jameson. When a septic tank is not properly maintained, it can lead to leaks and overflow, which in turn can saturate the surrounding soil. The smell you described, the gurgling sounds in the drains, even the health issues your family is experiencing—all of these are signs that the septic system is likely compromised.”


Jameson looked stricken, as if the weight of Holmes’ words had only just begun to settle in. “But surely, Mr. Holmes, there must be some other explanation? A problem with the pipes, perhaps? Or the drains?”


Holmes shook his head slowly. “The evidence suggests otherwise. However, I will need to inspect the exterior of the house to confirm my suspicions. Dr. Watson and I will examine the area near the septic tank and see if there are any signs of leakage or other issues.”


Without waiting for a response, Holmes led the way out of the kitchen and toward the back of the house. I followed closely, noticing how his demeanor had shifted—his earlier curiosity had given way to a determined resolve. We stepped out into the garden, the cool air a welcome relief from the stuffiness inside.


The garden, much like the rest of the property, showed signs of neglect. Weeds choked the flower beds, and the grass was overgrown and patchy. Holmes moved swiftly, heading directly to the area where Jameson had mentioned the ground was soft. He crouched down, examining the earth with a practiced eye.


“This soil is saturated,” Holmes said after a moment, scooping up a handful of the dark, wet earth. “And the smell is stronger here, though less noticeable in the open air. It’s likely that the septic tank is leaking, and the waste is seeping into the ground.”


I leaned down to inspect the area myself. The ground was indeed soft, and as I pressed my hand against it, I felt a slight give, as if there was something unstable beneath the surface.


Holmes stood up, brushing the dirt from his hands. “Mr. Jameson,” he called, “I fear the situation is quite serious. Your septic system has been neglected for too long, and it is now in a state of failure. We will need to arrange for a thorough inspection and immediate repairs.”


Jameson, who had been lingering at the doorway, approached us with a look of dawning horror. “But Mr. Holmes, I had no idea... I never thought...”


Holmes placed a reassuring hand on his shoulder. “Do not be too hard on yourself, Mr. Jameson. Many homeowners are unaware of the importance of regular septic maintenance until it is too late. However, the good news is that this issue can be resolved. With proper care and attention, your home will be safe again.”


As we walked back to the house, I couldn’t help but admire Holmes’ ability to piece together the puzzle so quickly. What had seemed like a mysterious and possibly supernatural occurrence was, in fact, a case of simple neglect—yet one with potentially dire consequences.


Holmes, ever the pragmatist, had seen through the confusion to the heart of the matter. And as we prepared to leave the Jameson residence, I knew that the next steps would be crucial in preventing further harm to the family and their home.


Cliff Notes:


1. Septic system failure can cause the ground to become saturated and boggy.

- Holmes identifies the soft ground near the back of the house as a sign of leakage from the septic tank.


2. Gurgling sounds in the drains are a common symptom of septic system issues.

- The gurgling sounds described by Mr. Jameson lead Holmes to suspect a problem with the septic system.


3. Neglecting a septic system can result in serious consequences, including leaks and overflow.

- Holmes explains to Mr. Jameson that the failure to maintain the septic system has likely led to its current state of disrepair.



0 views0 comments

Comments


bottom of page